Soc 490: Prompt # 2 “Explore the other side of the debate in
relation to universal healthcare. Healthcare is a universal right in the United
States. ”
In my
first blog, I argued that universal healthcare was not a right and that people
were not entitled to have it given to them without some sort of effort on their
part. This blog will be completely opposite as I strive to argue the other side
of the debate. You can’t fully understand your own side of the argument until
you fully understand the other side first. Helen Redmond is the author of one
of the articles that is in favor of healthcare being a right. She states that “at
the core of the idea that healthcare is a human right is freedom. The United
restricts our freedom in relation to healthcare. Instead of freedom, there is
fear.”
That in
favor of saying that universal healthcare is a right believe that everyone is
entitled to healthcare no matter what the circumstances are. One major theme
portrayed is in relation to the mentally ill. Millions of adults and children
suffer from a variety of mental illnesses including anxiety, depression,
schizophrenia, etc. Insurers avoid covering these mentally disabled people
because they are too much of a risk to insure because of the cost. What are
these people supposed to do? Are they supposed to fight for themselves on the
street? Most of them end up in jail, or something similar.
Another
major aspect of those in favor of universal healthcare is those that are
addicted to substances. Some of which are their fault, others that are not.
Redmond says that “Those with addictions
are discriminated against because healthcare providers refuse them due to long
term treatment costs.” There were 1.5
million people in Illinois that didn’t get treatment that couldn’t afford it.
Some of those died because they overdosed waiting to get treatment. The same
question still stands. Are those people supposed to fight for themselves on the
streets since they cant afford care? Again, some of them end up in jail, and
some even end up dead.
The
cost of healthcare and the overall debt that is accumulated for some people is
something that universal healthcare will supposedly cure in the long run.
According to Redmond and a study within the article, “the uninsured have an
average credit card debt of $14,512 due to medical debt and those with
insurance have $10,973.” Those who owe this money are not free. Redmond says
that this trap is what leads people to have their freedom taken away. For some,
this eventually leads to job lock where they are stuck at a job solely based on
the healthcare benefits that are offered because they are scared of losing that
benefit if they leave. Overall, these major reasons are what influences those
to vie for a healthcare system that is universal. Fear should not be the basis
of the healthcare system in the United States. It should be the freedom.
Dan,
ReplyDeleteGreat blog. You almost had me convinced that you believed health care was a right.
If I didn't know your position in the first blog, I would think you were in favor of universal health care. Nice work explaining this position. Keep up the great work.
Nice job Dan. I liked how effortlessly you argued the opposite side of your previous blog. I fully agree with you on the point about the mentally ill. These people suffer from a multitude of factors and many of them can't control what is happening to them. These people do deserve the RIGHT to universal healthcare. Otherwise, it would be morally wrong for us to completely disregard them. Keep intriguing me.
ReplyDeleteReally enjoyed reading your blog Dan. I like how you used Helen's quote about people being in fear rather than free, I did as well. Even when arguing against what we really believe we learn if our side is truly unbeatable. I think that think quote by Helen would be hard for anyone to disagree with no matter what side they are on. I also read Marks blog, and I told him the same thing, I really believed you were on this side while reading it! I think it is great you seem to know both sides very strongly. I also liked how you ended your blog talking about freedom again, really wrapped it all up for the reader! Can't wait to read more of your blogs!
ReplyDeleteHey Dan great blog!
ReplyDeleteVery great argument, very convincing argument about healthcare being a right.
ReplyDeleteI think it might have been a better one then your original. You might need to change your view point.
ReplyDeleteGreat blog i enjoyed reading it.
ReplyDeleteWeldon, you need to wait and finish your comment before publishing every sentence in your comment.
ReplyDelete